Modi 2.0 first budget: Paralleling China`s miraculous growth path

The latest budget presented by the new Modi government has set a very ambitious target for the Indian economy - reach a US $5 trillion GDP figure from the present US$ 2.7 trillion. If the present government targets to achieve this figure by the end of their term in 2024, as proposed, it would mean a real annual GDP growth of a staggering 13%!!!

China growth path, even though not openly admitted by the Indian government, obviously is one of the drivers for this budget. As the saying goes “If you can’t lick them join them “. China`s investment led development model with focus on mega factories, infrastructure, easy access to credit from financial institutions and attracting global investments which was backed by a strong government policy making machinery is evident as one of the key motivators of the Indian government`s initiatives.

Let’s look at some of the intent-based proposals in the budget which are very similar to what China did:

1.    Growth in fixed investment - Mega factories are being encouraged, very similar to the mega SEZ`s that powered China, to boost investment as well as create jobs that will in turn boost consumption. This initiative is also in tune with the “Make in India” initiative of the Prime Minister. However, this initiative is highly dependent upon the private investments which have been facing issues like land acquisition, high interest rates and poor infrastructure issues. External investors, who are being wooed, are still skeptical about investments especially when the global economic front is looking increasingly fragile.

2.    Infrastructure Development - The Indian government wants to give a massive boost to infrastructure - railway sector, roads, ports, airports and power and newly created water distribution. The railway infrastructure, which needs about Rs 50,000Cr, is proposed to be boosted with PPP`s the effectiveness of which however is still under a cloud.  Credit flow from the financial institutions, which are reeling from the excesses post 2009 crisis and the present NBFC crisis, is one of the key determinants for the success of the PPP initiative.

3.    Cheaper credit - China fueled its growth by making its banks lend indiscriminately to the borrowers leading to the wobbly banking sector very similar to what India is also facing now. Hence to bring down the interest rates the government proposes external borrowing by taking advantage of low and negative interest rates in many countries which will help the government to fund its projects at low rates.

4.    Focus on sustainability and green initiatives - Something that China missed and hence paying for its sins with its pollution problems in many cities. The Indian government is incentivizing Electric Vehicles (EV`s) which apart from giving push to the languishing car manufacturing industry will also address the sustainability issues. The government has also proposed a social exchange under SEBI which will address social development issues – something which will ensure a “equitable development” of the society.

5.    Focus on MSME and SME - These sectors are India`s answers to job creation and drive growth especially in the manufacturing sector. The government needs to address the issues of credit flow, labor movement before these sectors can boom.

Challenges that will be faced....

China based on the above model powered itself to the world`s second largest economy by following the above model from the 1980`s which bore fruit from the 2000`s. The Modi government similarly has laid the path for India becoming a $5 trillion economy by taking many cues from China. However, the point to be noted is that China took at least 10-15 years, during which it built its base like infrastructure, before it became a fast-growing economy. Secondly, China was ruthless in implementation of its objectives for which one of the major reasons was the single party rule. India will have its challenges as it’s a full-fledged democracy.

Long time back I came across a saying when I was working with a top-notch consultancy firm – “All strategy documents are a piece of toilet paper unless implemented properly”. The Modi government hence may take cue from it and focus on proper implementation and ground level reach of all its proposals. The ruling party has a majority in the Lower House - Lok Sabha and moving towards one in the Upper House – Rajya Sabha and hence if it has the will, can take India to its cherished dream of $5 trillion economy!

Hope for the best.